Learned On...

When Pink Repels Men: Marketing “Womens’ Products” to Men

Are more men buying female-targeted skincare and beauty products and treatments? Apparently so – but these guys must be bold enough to brave the department store make-up counter or the night cream aisle at the grocery store – a very female realm. So, what’s a guy to do? Head online and stay under the radar (have his wife or girlfriend buy it for him).

There’s an interesting discussion of this in today’s RetailWire. Because men do still feel they have to hide this sort of purchase, I think this is a trend that may be slow to build (mainly because it will be hard to verify). Here are two excerpts from my comment on that discussion:

In doing research into how traditionally male-dominated industries
market to women, I am also exploring how traditionally female-oriented
industries (beauty/apparel, for one) tend to unnecessarily alienate a
lot of male prospects by, well…being too “pink” in their approach.
So–yes–men want nice haircuts and are willing to pay, but it may be
too “girly” to admit it or be seen in a salon.

My thought–that women may now be a lot more comfortable entering a
man’s consumer realm than vice versa–especially since marketers in the more obvious womens’ categories (hair, makeup, skincare) have
perhaps gone the superficial route to reaching women (by overly
“feminizing” an approach rather than simply striving to serve higher
standards).

***

In the meantime, pink and cartoon illustrations of hip women continue to be the trend for marketing women-specific products, though Today Sponge calls its color scheme “wine and fuchsia.” I’m not so sure about that – but I do appreciate the site’s attempt to get women telling their stories and interacting with the brand and one another about the issue of contraception. Check out the New York Times article by Jane L. Levere (reg. required) for more.

Bookmark and Share
  • http://www.makeuptip.com Makeup

    You’re right. My husband usually makes me go to the skincare department and make his purchase. His manliness is getting the btter of him…

  • http://ethmar.com Ethan

    I’ve been thinking about your “pink thinking” by way of my forays into scrapbooking. There’s a very “pink” industry, and one that on the one hand wants more male involvement (read: money), but on the other, is unabashedly “pink” in their approach to marketing, etc. Heck, even the tools, which guys love (grin), are pink, which turns guys off. Some vendors are wising up and making their tools more neutral, but since men make up such a small segment of the market I’m not sure how much interest there will be to get away from “pink thinking”.

    It’s interesting to see a one-sided market that technically could be more gender neutral deal with the decision to do so pro or con, anyway.

  • http://www.learnedonwomen.com Andrea Learned

    I agree, Ethan. “Gender neutrality” seems too difficult for marketers to comprehend in this day and age. It seems, in a way, a bit sexier to focus on one gender or the other, even if it is unnecessary. Not sure why.

    The more important market profile characteristics are definitely things like scrapbooking fanaticism, or shared interests, roles or life stages (parents of young children, for example). Who knows when pink marketers will ride out the extreme male-female pendulum swing of marketing trends to reach that point of view?